fat ronaldo was maybe the bestof his generatioon but nowhere near goat
#1
he had zero longevity, was always injured

like he already  was game over at 30yo, while cristiano is still decent at 40
Reply
#2
1. ronaldinho
2. ronaldo
3. zidane

longevity = irrelevant
peak performance = everything
(18-09-2025, 06:49 PM)MVP Wrote: i already said, rӏ is built different

Quote:[Image: Screenshot-2026-06-20-at-23-46-52-Lookis...-Lists.png]
Reply
#3
he might be the most overrated player to ever exist, lmao

it's stroke inducing that people put him in their "best 11" over cristiano

I rate romario above him
Reply
#4
(01-03-2025, 02:22 AM)Altruist Wrote: 1. ronaldinho
2. ronaldo
3. zidane

longevity = irrelevant
peak performance = everything

his peak season had less goals than cr7/messi's 8th best season or so

and he was a pure striker while the others were winger and false 9
Reply
#5
(01-03-2025, 02:24 AM)kathisterima Wrote: he might be the most overrated player to ever exist, lmao

it's stroke inducing that people put him in their "best 11" over cristiano

I rate romario above him

you can do better
(18-09-2025, 06:49 PM)MVP Wrote: i already said, rӏ is built different

Quote:[Image: Screenshot-2026-06-20-at-23-46-52-Lookis...-Lists.png]
Reply
#6
(01-03-2025, 02:26 AM)kathisterima Wrote: his peak season had less goals than cr7/messi's 8th best season or so

and he was a pure striker while the others were winger and false 9

can someone explain what peak means to this guy
(18-09-2025, 06:49 PM)MVP Wrote: i already said, rӏ is built different

Quote:[Image: Screenshot-2026-06-20-at-23-46-52-Lookis...-Lists.png]
Reply
#7
(01-03-2025, 02:29 AM)Altruist Wrote: can someone explain what peak means to this guy

can you, because it clearly means something different to you than to the rest of us
Reply
#8
(01-03-2025, 02:30 AM)kathisterima Wrote: can you, because it clearly means something different to you than to the rest of us

tag me tomorrow and i will (srs)
(18-09-2025, 06:49 PM)MVP Wrote: i already said, rӏ is built different

Quote:[Image: Screenshot-2026-06-20-at-23-46-52-Lookis...-Lists.png]
Reply
#9
there is without a doubt that messi and cristiano are battling for the goat status

its not even close

only ronaldinho in his peak could battle with them for goat status but he had zero longevity


Fat ronaldo would be lucky to be in the top 10, i prefer xavi and inesta over fat ronaldo

maradona and pele also better, neymar is better 

then zidane is probably fat ronaldo tier


if i had to make a top 10


1. C. Ronaldo
2. Messi
3. Ronaldhino
4. Neymar
5. Inesta
6. Xavi
7. Özil
8. Maradona
9. Pele
10. Zidane/Fat Ronaldo THOUGH TBH I THINK lewandowski and saurez could mog them as strikers, mbappe haaland are close too)

Patrick Kluivert is good too

Romario i Bebeto...

yeah maybe johan cruyff, di stefano and van basten are up there too, like beckenbauer and PLATINI

idk i dont put defenders in top 10, though there are also good like Lahm and R. Carlos, Ramos pepe. Marcelo i Coentrao, dani alves, busquets, Kroos, and  Filippo Inzaghi
Reply
#10
what is ozil doing there lmao
Reply
#11
(01-03-2025, 03:01 AM)kathisterima Wrote: what is ozil doing there lmao

best offensive passer statistically (xavi and iniesta were more defensive passers), he helped c. ronaldo score many goals, and mourinho is the best coach he said özil is top tier. özil is like the dream assistant of a goalgetter

i liked how he plaid the game in a disinterested way but high iq

look at the last goal how cold he passed to müller



look some özil passing videos
Reply
#12
Reply
#13
how is he statistically tha best, players like kroos kdb modric have more assists and higher forawrd passing accuracy

id put someone like kaka or zidane on 10 because they can do more things than assist, especially kaka who had crazy pace and was top scorer for milan in many seasons
Reply
#14
i think this is the most effective soccer 11:

Buffon
Lahm Ramos Pepe R.Carlos
Busquets
Xavi Iniesta
Özil
Messi C.ronaldo
Reply
#15
(01-03-2025, 03:34 AM)kathisterima Wrote: how is he statistically tha best, players like kroos kdb modric have more assists and higher forawrd passing accuracy

id put someone like kaka or zidane on 10 because they can do more things than assist, especially kaka who had crazy pace and was top scorer for milan in many seasons

kaka seems to have been forgotten way too easily
(18-09-2025, 06:49 PM)MVP Wrote: i already said, rӏ is built different

Quote:[Image: Screenshot-2026-06-20-at-23-46-52-Lookis...-Lists.png]
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: