(19-11-2025, 08:10 AM)mogs_me Wrote: 4 > 3 > 6 > 2 > 1 > 5 > 7 > 8

only seasons 3+4 I would say are consistently good
it does drag on at times
my main criticism is it lacks originality, feels like anything some fantasy nerd could've written
but it is generally well executed: solid dialogue (except for a few moments, e.g. bad pussy), good character development (except for a few characters towards the end of the show, hot take: jaime wasn't one of them), good acting (with a few exceptions such as sophie turner), interesting plot most of the time, ok yeah everything here has an exception but it was a large show it's not gonna be perfect etc
i think it has very little rewatch value as your brain subconsciously understands anything positive will be ruined by last 2 seasons

(19-11-2025, 08:10 AM)mogs_me Wrote: 4 > 3 > 6 > 2 > 1 > 5 > 7 > 8

only seasons 3+4 I would say are consistently good
it does drag on at times
my main criticism is it lacks originality, feels like anything some fantasy nerd could've written
but it is generally well executed: solid dialogue (except for a few moments, e.g. bad pussy), good character development (except for a few characters towards the end of the show, hot take: jaime wasn't one of them), good acting (with a few exceptions such as sophie turner), interesting plot most of the time, ok yeah everything here has an exception but it was a large show it's not gonna be perfect etc
i think it has very little rewatch value as your brain subconsciously understands anything positive will be ruined by last 2 seasons

(19-11-2025, 08:18 AM)mogs_me Wrote: also the fucking scene where oberyn is approaching tyrion about being his champion and he talks about cersei "pinching [baby tyrion]'s cock so hard [oberyn] was scared it would fall off" like why are you putting this in? what does this add? why are we discussing incestuous genital mutilation/sexual assault in this particular situation? ruins an otherwise great scene

yeah some shit about this show does make me mad but it's entertaining for the most part

(19-11-2025, 08:19 AM)n9wiff Wrote: It's better than most shows, they just have made a lot of weird changes when deviating from ASOIAF

(19-11-2025, 08:22 AM)mogs_me Wrote: another complaint: tobias menzies's (edmure) acting skills were completely wasted on the role he was given
just adding things here as i think of them

(19-11-2025, 10:59 AM)Achathin Wrote: a show which is made for the iq range of 80-90 and is at its core soft core porn has shit writing?

its a female show anyway why tf would a a male watch basically a sex novel

(19-11-2025, 02:38 PM)Altruist Wrote: Holy brainlet take

(19-11-2025, 02:45 PM)Shrekcel Wrote: Virgin discussions

(20-11-2025, 01:20 AM)Arrogans Wrote: Loved it so much, in my top 3-5 for sure, I kinda disliked Emilia Clarke or whatever, didn't consider her acting that good in the show, Lannisters were great.